When a company borrows money, the lender may request security over the company’s assets. This security is often created through a document known as a debenture.
Debentures are common in commercial lending, but their wording can be extensive and their consequences significant. They may give a lender rights over property, equipment, money, debts owed to the company and other business assets.
Directors and shareholders should understand how the debenture fits into the wider finance arrangement, particularly where they are also being asked to provide a personal guarantee or security over personal property.
What Is a Company Debenture?
A debenture is a legal document that creates security over some or all of a company’s assets in favour of a lender.
It may include:
- Fixed charges over particular assets
- Floating charges over changing business assets
- Restrictions on dealing with secured property
- Ongoing information obligations
- Events that place the company in default
- Powers available to the lender following default
The debenture supports the company’s repayment obligations under a separate loan or facility agreement.
What Is a Fixed Charge?
A fixed charge is generally attached to a particular asset or category of assets.
Examples may include:
- Land and commercial property
- Machinery
- Intellectual property
- Certain bank accounts
- Specific investments
- Valuable equipment
The company may be restricted from selling, transferring or creating further security over a fixed-charge asset without the lender’s consent.
This gives the lender a significant degree of control over the secured property.
What Is a Floating Charge?
A floating charge can cover assets that change during the normal operation of the business.
This may include:
- Stock
- Raw materials
- Work in progress
- Certain receivables
- Other circulating business assets
The company may ordinarily continue dealing with these assets while trading. Following certain events, however, the lender’s rights may become enforceable and the company’s freedom to use those assets may be restricted.
The precise position depends on the terms of the debenture and the circumstances at the time.
Why Might Independent Legal Advice Be Needed?
The company will usually have its own solicitor dealing with the finance transaction. However, separate independent advice may be required where a director, shareholder or third party is entering into additional personal obligations.
This can arise where the individual is asked to:
- Provide a personal guarantee
- Charge their home or another property
- Postpone money owed to them by the company
- Sign an indemnity
- Provide security over personally owned assets
- Accept obligations that are separate from their role as a director
Independent legal advice ensures the solicitor is advising the individual rather than the company or lender.
What Could Happen if the Company Defaults?
The lender’s available options will depend on the finance and security documents.
Potential consequences may include:
- Demanding immediate repayment
- Enforcing fixed security
- Restricting the use of secured assets
- Taking control of certain asset sale proceeds
- Exercising contractual appointment powers
- Pursuing personal guarantors
- Enforcing a legal charge over personal property
A director should therefore consider the debenture alongside every related document rather than viewing it in isolation.
What Should Directors Check Before Signing?
Important questions include:
Which liabilities are secured?
Does the debenture secure one particular loan, or does it cover all money the company may owe the lender?
Which assets are included?
Does the security apply to selected assets or substantially all of the company’s present and future assets?
What restrictions apply?
Will the company need consent before selling assets, borrowing elsewhere, paying dividends or changing its structure?
What counts as a default?
Default may extend beyond a missed repayment and could include a breach of another obligation or a material change in the company’s position.
Are personal guarantees also required?
A debenture secures the lender against company assets. A personal guarantee may create separate liability for an individual.
Is there already existing security?
The company may already have another lender with security over its assets. The relationship and priority between lenders may need to be addressed.
Is a Debenture the Same as a Personal Guarantee?
No.
A debenture generally creates security over assets owned by the company. A personal guarantee is a promise by an individual to meet the borrower’s obligations if the borrower fails to do so.
A lender may require both:
- The debenture provides access to company assets.
- The personal guarantee provides a potential claim against the guarantor.
A director should understand each document and the combined level of exposure.
Can a Director Be Personally Liable Under a Debenture?
A debenture given by a limited company does not automatically make its directors personally liable for the debt.
Personal exposure may arise through separate documents, such as a guarantee, indemnity or legal charge. It can also arise in other specific circumstances, but these require advice based on the individual facts.
Never assume that signing “as a director” means every document is limited to a corporate obligation. Check the signature blocks and the capacity in which you are entering into each agreement.
Why Early Advice Is Important
Commercial finance transactions often move quickly, particularly where funds are needed for an acquisition, property purchase or urgent cash-flow requirement.
However, waiting until the planned completion date to obtain advice can create problems if:
- Documents are missing
- The lender has additional requirements
- Separate representation is necessary
- The individual does not understand the risks
- Changes need to be discussed
- Identity checks have not been completed
Arrange the appointment as soon as the lender confirms that independent advice is required.
Arrange Independent Advice on a Debenture or Related Guarantee
A debenture can give a lender extensive security over the assets a company needs to operate. Where directors or shareholders are also taking on personal obligations, it is particularly important to understand the distinction between company security and personal liability.
The ILA Experts provide independent advice on debentures, personal guarantees and related commercial finance documents. We explain the key provisions clearly so you can understand your position before signing.
Book an independent legal advice appointment or read more about our debenture and commercial agreement services.
What assets can be covered by a debenture?
A debenture may cover property, machinery, intellectual property, stock, receivables, bank accounts and other present or future company assets.
Is a debenture a loan?
No. The loan or facility agreement contains the borrowing terms. The debenture provides security for the company’s obligations. Potentially, but the owners and lender will need to satisfy the necessary legal and registration requirements. Each owner may need separate advice depending on the transaction.
Does signing a debenture make a director personally liable?
Not automatically. Personal liability usually arises through a separate guarantee, indemnity or security document.
Can a company have more than one debenture?
Potentially, although the priority between lenders and any restrictions in existing finance documents must be considered.
Do directors need separate legal advice?
Separate advice may be required where a director is accepting personal obligations or where the company’s solicitor cannot independently advise the individual.